Education + News

Allow Pearl to keep you informed and up to date on events and topics relevant to the trucking and transportation industry.

 

Liability Implications of Improperly Trained Drivers

May 6, 2025

When a commercial truck is involved in an accident, one of the first questions asked is: Was the driver properly trained? For trucking company owners and general managers, the answer to that question can carry serious legal and financial consequences. Inadequate or inconsistent training is a key factor in many preventable accidents—and when a crash occurs, plaintiff attorneys are quick to scrutinize the driver’s training records. If your company can’t prove that a driver was properly trained, it opens the door to liability lawsuits, higher settlement payouts, and even nuclear verdicts.

Improperly trained drivers also impact your company’s CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability) scores, which are closely monitored by the FMCSA. Poor safety scores can trigger audits, lead to costly fines, and result in being flagged for increased roadside inspections. Insurance carriers also track these scores, and if they see frequent violations tied to driver behavior, they may increase premiums—or worse, decline to renew your policy. In this way, the absence of a robust, documented driver training program directly affects both your insurability and bottom line.

To mitigate these risks, fleets must go beyond entry-level driver training and adopt a system of ongoing driver education. This includes defensive driving, safe backing techniques, hours-of-service compliance, and updates on DOT regulations. A best practice is to use a data-driven approach—pairing telematics data and motor vehicle record (MVR) monitoring with customized training based on individual driver behavior. This allows safety managers to identify patterns, intervene early, and provide remedial training before small mistakes turn into catastrophic incidents.

Ultimately, the legal and financial exposure from undertrained drivers can be devastating for trucking companies. But it’s also preventable. By investing in consistent, well-documented, and behavior-based driver training, you demonstrate a clear commitment to safety and compliance. This not only reduces crash risk—it strengthens your legal defense, improves your safety scores, and helps maintain reasonable insurance premiums. In today’s high-stakes transportation environment, proper driver training isn’t optional—it’s essential for protecting your fleet and your future.